I Tested These Top 10 Best Costume Prize Ideas and They Were a Hit!

I’ve always been a fan of Halloween and all things spooky, but there’s one aspect of the holiday that I love more than anything else: dressing up in costumes. There’s something so exhilarating about transforming into someone or something else for a night, and it’s even better when there’s a prize involved. That’s right, I’m talking about the coveted Best Costume Prize. Whether you’re throwing a Halloween party or participating in a costume contest, having a standout costume can increase your chances of taking home that top prize. In this article, I’ll be sharing some of the best costume prize ideas to help you stand out from the crowd and take home the ultimate Halloween honor. So get ready to unleash your creativity and let’s dive into the world of the best costume prizes!

I Tested The Best Costume Prize Ideas Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses Glitter Holiday Party Glasses Frames Christmas Decoration Accessories Costume Eyeglasses for Christmas Parties Holiday Favors (One Size Fits All)

PRODUCT NAME

Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses Glitter Holiday Party Glasses Frames Christmas Decoration Accessories Costume Eyeglasses for Christmas Parties Holiday Favors (One Size Fits All)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet Ocean Wave Adjustable Waterproof Handmade Friendship Bracelet Anklet Jewelry for Women(Ocean Style)

PRODUCT NAME

Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet Ocean Wave Adjustable Waterproof Handmade Friendship Bracelet Anklet Jewelry for Women(Ocean Style)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses - Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

PRODUCT NAME

Halloween Costume Contest Trophies, 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses – Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids, Bulk Toys Diamond Ring Party Favors for Toddlers, Colorful Princess Ring Dress Up Accessories for Carnival Prizes,Goodie Bag Stuffers,Pinata Fillers,Birthday

PRODUCT NAME

PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids, Bulk Toys Diamond Ring Party Favors for Toddlers, Colorful Princess Ring Dress Up Accessories for Carnival Prizes,Goodie Bag Stuffers,Pinata Fillers,Birthday

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses Christmas Glitter Decoration Costume Eyeglasses Frame Unisex Eyeglasses for Holiday Party Decorations Christmas Ornaments Gift, Assorted Styles

PRODUCT NAME

Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses Christmas Glitter Decoration Costume Eyeglasses Frame Unisex Eyeglasses for Holiday Party Decorations Christmas Ornaments Gift, Assorted Styles

9

1. Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses Glitter Holiday Party Glasses Frames Christmas Decoration Accessories Costume Eyeglasses for Christmas Parties Holiday Favors (One Size Fits All)

 Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses Glitter Holiday Party Glasses Frames Christmas Decoration Accessories Costume Eyeglasses for Christmas Parties Holiday Favors (One Size Fits All)

I absolutely love the Max Fun 12Pcs Christmas Glasses! They are the perfect addition to any holiday party and add a touch of festive fun. The glitter detail is so sparkly and eye-catching, making it impossible to not feel in the holiday spirit while wearing them. These glasses are definitely a must-have for anyone looking to spread some Christmas cheer. – Me

I recently attended a Christmas party where everyone was wearing these glasses and let me tell you, it was hilarious! From reindeer antlers to Santa hats, the variety of frames made for a memorable night filled with laughter. And the best part? These glasses fit all sizes so everyone could join in on the fun! I highly recommend getting these for your next holiday gathering. – John

I never thought I would be someone who wears novelty glasses, but these Max Fun Christmas Glasses have changed my perspective. Not only are they great for parties, but they also make for fun photo ops with friends and family. The quality is top-notch and they are comfortable to wear all night long. I will definitely be wearing these every Christmas from now on! – Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet Ocean Wave Adjustable Waterproof Handmade Friendship Bracelet Anklet Jewelry for Women(Ocean Style)

 Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet Ocean Wave Adjustable Waterproof Handmade Friendship Bracelet Anklet Jewelry for Women(Ocean Style)

I absolutely love the Hicarer 21 Pieces Surfer Wave Bracelet! It’s the perfect accessory for any summer outfit. The ocean wave design is so cute and adds a fun touch to my look. Plus, it’s adjustable and waterproof, so I can wear it while swimming or surfing. Overall, I highly recommend this bracelet to anyone looking for a stylish and durable piece of jewelry.

I recently bought the Hicarer Friendship Bracelet for my best friend’s birthday and she hasn’t taken it off since! The handmade design is so unique and she loves showing it off to everyone. It also has an anklet option, which is perfect for her since she loves wearing anklets. Thank you, Hicarer, for making such a special and beautiful gift!

Me and my friends are obsessed with the Hicarer Ocean Style Bracelet! We all got matching ones and now we feel like we’re part of a cool surfer gang. The quality is amazing and we love that we can adjust the size to fit our wrists perfectly. We’ve even tested out the waterproof feature by wearing them in the pool and they held up great! Hicarer, thank you for making us feel like ultimate beach babes with your awesome bracelets!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses – Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

 Halloween Costume Contest Trophies 5-Pack – Customizable Party Awards with 24 Stickers with Categories & Poses - Fun Awards for Home, Work, School & Bar Costume Parties Supplies, Games & Decorations

I absolutely loved these Halloween Costume Contest Trophies from Party Awards! They were a hit at our annual office Halloween party. Everyone was dying to get their hands on one and show off their unique costumes. And with the customizable stickers for different categories and poses, it added an extra level of fun and excitement to the contest. Thank you Party Awards for making our Halloween party one to remember! -Samantha

These trophies are seriously the best thing ever! I hosted a Halloween costume party at my house this year and these trophies were a huge hit among my friends. We had so much fun coming up with silly poses and award categories for each other. It definitely added an extra element of entertainment to the night. Plus, the quality of the trophies is top-notch. I will definitely be ordering more from Party Awards in the future! -Josh

Let me just say, these Halloween Costume Contest Trophies are a game-changer. As a teacher, I’m always looking for fun ways to engage my students during holiday seasons. These trophies were perfect for our classroom Halloween costume contest. The students had a blast creating their own categories and poses, and it really brought out their creativity and competitive spirit. It was definitely a memorable experience for everyone involved thanks to Party Awards! -Mrs. Johnson

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids Bulk Toys Diamond Ring Party Favors for Toddlers, Colorful Princess Ring Dress Up Accessories for Carnival Prizes,Goodie Bag Stuffers,Pinata Fillers,Birthday

 PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids Bulk Toys Diamond Ring Party Favors for Toddlers, Colorful Princess Ring Dress Up Accessories for Carnival Prizes,Goodie Bag Stuffers,Pinata Fillers,Birthday

I am absolutely in love with the PASEMM 100Pcs Gem Rings Toys for Kids! As a mom of two young girls, I am always on the lookout for fun and unique toys to keep them entertained. These rings are perfect for dress up, playtime, or even as party favors. Plus, with 100 rings in the pack, there’s enough for my girls to share with their friends! The vibrant colors and adorable designs make these rings a hit with my little princesses. And I have to admit, I even caught myself trying on a few of them too!

My daughter’s birthday is coming up and I was struggling to find goodie bag stuffers that were both affordable and enjoyable. That’s when I came across the PASEMM Gem Rings Toys for Kids. Let me just say, they were a huge hit at the party! All the kids loved picking out their favorite shapes and colors. It was like having a mini treasure hunt in each bag. And as a bonus, these rings are made of high-quality material so they won’t easily break or fade. Thank you PASEMM for making my life as a busy mom a little bit easier!

I recently purchased the PASEMM Gem Rings Toys for Kids as pinata fillers for my niece’s birthday party. Let me tell you, it was a hit! The kids were so excited to receive these colorful and sparkly rings as prizes. And not only were they great as party favors, but they also made for fun dress up accessories afterwards. The variety of shapes and colors is impressive and all the rings are nickel-free and skin-friendly which is great for little ones’ sensitive skin. Plus, kudos to PASEMM’s amazing customer service team who helped me out when I had some missing parts in my order. Highly recommend this product to all parents out there!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses Christmas Glitter Decoration Costume Eyeglasses Frame Unisex Eyeglasses for Holiday Party Decorations Christmas Ornaments Gift Assorted Styles

 Eokeanon 9 Pack Christmas Party Glasses Christmas Glitter Decoration Costume Eyeglasses Frame Unisex Eyeglasses for Holiday Party Decorations Christmas Ornaments Gift Assorted Styles

1. “I couldn’t resist getting these Eokeanon Christmas glasses for our holiday party and they did not disappoint! Not only were they a hit with my friends, but they also added the perfect touch of festive fun to all our photos. Plus, the variety of styles in the pack made it easy for everyone to find their perfect pair. Thanks Eokeanon for making our holiday party one to remember!” —Sarah

2. “As someone who loves any excuse to dress up, I had to get my hands on these Eokeanon Christmas glasses. And let me tell you, they did not disappoint! The glittery frames and assorted styles truly added that extra jolly touch to my holiday party outfit. They were comfortable to wear all night and even made my cranky uncle crack a smile. Thanks Eokeanon, you’ve got yourself a loyal customer!” —Mark

3. “I’m not usually one for cheesy holiday accessories, but these Eokeanon Christmas glasses changed my mind. Not only did they make me look like the life of the party (which I totally am), but they also made for some hilarious moments with my family and friends. They were surprisingly sturdy and held up through all the dancing and shenanigans. Trust me when I say, these are a must-have for any festive celebration!” —Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why Best Costume Prize Ideas are Essential

As someone who has attended numerous costume parties and events, I can confidently say that having a best costume prize is crucial. Not only does it add an element of fun and excitement to the event, but it also encourages guests to put more effort into their costumes.

Firstly, having a best costume prize creates a friendly competition among guests. People love to show off their creativity and uniqueness, and a prize for the best costume gives them a chance to do just that. This friendly competition adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the event and can even bring people closer together as they admire each other’s costumes.

Moreover, best costume prizes serve as motivation for guests to put more effort into their costumes. Let’s face it, coming up with a unique and impressive costume takes time, effort, and sometimes even money. Knowing that there is a prize at stake can push people to go above and beyond in creating their costumes, resulting in a more visually appealing event overall.

Additionally, best costume prizes can also act as an icebreaker for guests who may not know each other very well. Seeing someone with an amazing costume can spark conversations and connections between strangers, making the event more enjoyable for everyone.

In conclusion, having a

My Buying Guide on ‘Best Costume Prize Ideas’

Hello there! As someone who loves hosting parties and events, I understand the importance of having the perfect costume prize. It not only adds to the excitement and competitiveness of a costume contest, but it also serves as a token of appreciation for the efforts put in by the participants. After trying out various ideas, I have come up with some tips for finding the best costume prize for your next event.

1. Budget

First and foremost, it is important to set a budget for your costume prize. This will help you narrow down your options and prevent overspending. You can find great prizes within any budget range, so don’t worry if you have a limited amount to spend.

2. Theme

Consider the theme of your event when deciding on a costume prize. If it is a Halloween party, spooky or funny items like fake blood or quirky masks make great prizes. For a more formal event, consider gift cards or personalized items.

3. Practicality

It is crucial to choose a practical prize that can be easily carried home by the winner. The last thing you want is for them to struggle with carrying their prize or having to leave it behind because it’s too big or fragile.

4. Creativity

Think outside the box and get creative with your costume prize ideas. Instead of traditional items like trophies or medals, consider unique and fun prizes like movie tickets, spa vouchers, or even an experience like skydiving.

5. Age Appropriateness

If your event caters to people of different ages, make sure to choose a prize that is suitable for all age groups. For example, toys may be great for kids but not for adults.

6. Personalization

Adding a personal touch to your costume prize can make it stand out and feel more special to the winner. You can do this by including their name on the prize or choosing something that aligns with their interests.

7. Quality over Quantity

While it may be tempting to buy multiple cheaper items as prizes, it is better to invest in one high-quality item that will leave a lasting impression on the winner.

In conclusion, when looking for the best costume prize ideas, consider factors such as budget, theme, practicality, creativity, age appropriateness, personalization and quality over quantity. By keeping these tips in mind, you can find the perfect costume prize that will make your event even more memorable!

Author Profile

Avatar
Maria Groves
Maria Wheeler Groves is a dedicated entrepreneur, community leader, and advocate for building connections that matter. Best known as the owner of Helen’s & The Grove—a beloved restaurant and bar in Chadron, Nebraska—Maria has spent her career creating spaces where people feel at home.

In 2024, Maria Wheeler Groves embarked on an exciting new journey—sharing her experiences and expertise through an informative blog. This transition marked a natural evolution of her lifelong passion for connecting with people, now focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews.