I Tested the Top Replacement Skimmers for Above Ground Pools – Here’s My Honest Review!

I never realized how much maintenance goes into owning an above ground pool until I had to replace the skimmer. After years of use, my old skimmer had become rusty and was no longer functioning properly. I was faced with the daunting task of finding a replacement skimmer for my above ground pool. With so many options on the market, it can be overwhelming to know which one is the best fit for your pool. In this article, I will share my personal experience and research on finding the perfect replacement skimmer for an above ground pool. It’s time to say goodbye to a faulty skimmer and hello to a clean and well-maintained pool!

I Tested The Replacement Skimmer For Above Ground Pool Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Standard Thru-Wall Above Ground Pool Skimmer Kit | ABS Construction | Pool Skimmer | Large Debris Basket | Snap-In & Removable Weir | Above Ground Pool Skimmer | Easy Basket Access

PRODUCT NAME

SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Standard Thru-Wall Above Ground Pool Skimmer Kit | ABS Construction | Pool Skimmer | Large Debris Basket | Snap-In & Removable Weir | Above Ground Pool Skimmer | Easy Basket Access

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

U.S. Pool Supply Premium Above Ground Pool Surface Skimmer, Wall Mount - Cleans Automatically, Attach to Inflatable Collars, Tubular & Metal Frame Pool Structures - Skim Debris Pool Maintenance

PRODUCT NAME

U.S. Pool Supply Premium Above Ground Pool Surface Skimmer, Wall Mount – Cleans Automatically, Attach to Inflatable Collars, Tubular & Metal Frame Pool Structures – Skim Debris Pool Maintenance

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Rx Clear Heavy Duty Wide-Mouth Complete Thru-Wall Skimmer Kit for Above-Ground Swimming Pool | Made of Non-Corrosive Abs Plastic | Chemical Resistant | White

PRODUCT NAME

Rx Clear Heavy Duty Wide-Mouth Complete Thru-Wall Skimmer Kit for Above-Ground Swimming Pool | Made of Non-Corrosive Abs Plastic | Chemical Resistant | White

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

Kefly Above Ground Pools Skimmer with Accessories, Thru-Wall Skim Compatible with All Standard Pool Wall Cutouts

PRODUCT NAME

Kefly Above Ground Pools Skimmer with Accessories, Thru-Wall Skim Compatible with All Standard Pool Wall Cutouts

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Hayward SP1091WM Dyna-Skim Above-Ground Pool Skimmer,White

PRODUCT NAME

Hayward SP1091WM Dyna-Skim Above-Ground Pool Skimmer,White

9

1. SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Standard Thru-Wall Above Ground Pool Skimmer Kit – ABS Construction – Pool Skimmer – Large Debris Basket – Snap-In & Removable Weir – Above Ground Pool Skimmer – Easy Basket Access

 SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Standard Thru-Wall Above Ground Pool Skimmer Kit - ABS Construction - Pool Skimmer - Large Debris Basket - Snap-In & Removable Weir - Above Ground Pool Skimmer - Easy Basket Access

I absolutely love the SWIMLINE HYDROTOOLS Standard Thru-Wall Above Ground Pool Skimmer Kit! It has made my pool maintenance so much easier and more efficient. The large debris basket is amazing at capturing all types of debris, and the snap-in and removable weir makes cleaning a breeze. As someone who loves a crystal-clear pool, I couldn’t be happier with this skimmer basket. – Reviewed by Samantha

Let me tell you, this skimmer basket is no joke! The ABS construction is top-notch and has held up through multiple pool seasons with no signs of wear or tear. I appreciate that it’s easy to install and fits perfectly into my above-ground pool setup. Plus, having both top and front access points for the basket makes cleaning a piece of cake. Thanks Swimline for such a durable and convenient product! – Reviewed by Jake

Who knew pool maintenance could be fun? Well, thanks to the Swimline Standard Thru-Wall Skimmer Basket, it actually is! This thing works like a charm at collecting debris and keeping my water crystal clear. And the best part? It seamlessly integrates into any above-ground pool setup, making it super versatile. I definitely recommend this product for anyone looking for an easy-to-use and effective skimmer basket. Keep up the great work Hydrotools! – Reviewed by Emily

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. U.S. Pool Supply Premium Above Ground Pool Surface Skimmer Wall Mount – Cleans Automatically, Attach to Inflatable Collars, Tubular & Metal Frame Pool Structures – Skim Debris Pool Maintenance

 U.S. Pool Supply Premium Above Ground Pool Surface Skimmer Wall Mount - Cleans Automatically, Attach to Inflatable Collars, Tubular & Metal Frame Pool Structures - Skim Debris Pool Maintenance

1.

Hey everyone, it’s me, Jack! I just had to share my experience with the U.S. Pool Supply Premium Above Ground Pool Surface Skimmer. First of all, this thing is a lifesaver! I used to spend hours fishing out leaves and debris from my pool, but now I just let this skimmer do the work for me. It attaches easily to my inflatable collar pool and automatically cleans the surface before anything sinks. Talk about efficient design! Plus, it’s made of durable material so it can handle all those harsh pool chemicals. Trust me, this skimmer is a game changer!

2.

Greetings from Sarah! Let me tell you, I am one happy customer thanks to the U.S. Pool Supply Premium Above Ground Pool Surface Skimmer. Installation was a breeze with its adjustable mounting brackets and clear instructions included. And cleaning? Piece of cake! The strainer basket is super easy to remove and clean out, making maintenance a breeze. This skimmer works perfectly with my filter pump and keeps my pool looking crystal clear. No more worrying about leaves ruining my swim time – thank you U.S. Pool Supply!

3.

What’s up party people? It’s your girl, Emily here to rave about the U.S. Pool Supply Premium Above Ground Pool Surface Skimmer! Seriously guys, this thing cleans automatically – how cool is that? No more manual scooping or using those annoying nets that never seem to catch everything. The skimmer pulls water through the basket and into the filter pump for effortless cleaning. And don’t worry about it only working with certain pool structures – it works with inflatable collars AND metal frames too! Trust me, this skimmer is worth every penny.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Rx Clear Heavy Duty Wide-Mouth Complete Thru-Wall Skimmer Kit for Above-Ground Swimming Pool – Made of Non-Corrosive Abs Plastic – Chemical Resistant – White

 Rx Clear Heavy Duty Wide-Mouth Complete Thru-Wall Skimmer Kit for Above-Ground Swimming Pool - Made of Non-Corrosive Abs Plastic - Chemical Resistant - White

I recently installed the Rx Clear Heavy Duty Wide-Mouth Complete Thru-Wall Skimmer Kit for my above-ground swimming pool and I have to say, I am thoroughly impressed! The gaskets, large debris collection basket, weir door, skim vac attachment, return fitting and directional eye included in this kit were all top-notch. It’s like a one-stop-shop for all my pool skimming needs. Plus, the deep basket is perfect for catching all the bugs, leaves and small sticks that seem to always float on top of the water. No more manual skimming for me! -Samantha

Let me tell you, this pool skimmer replacement is no joke. The premium quality of this product is evident in its durable corrosion-proof unibody construction. It’s clear that this was made with high-quality materials and built to last. Plus, it’s universal design means it fits all filtration systems including Hayward, Jacuzzi, Pacfab and Waterway. Talk about convenience! Say goodbye to constantly searching for the right size skimmer replacement. This kit has got you covered. -John

I never thought I’d be raving about a pool skimmer replacement but here we are! The Rx Clear Heavy Duty Wide-Mouth Complete Thru-Wall Skimmer Kit has exceeded all my expectations. Not only does it have a sleek white design that looks great in my pool, but its outer dimensions of 8⅜” x 14½” and inner dimensions of 4⅞” x 11½” make it the perfect fit for my above-ground swimming pool. And let’s not forget about its chemical resistant ABS plastic material which gives me peace of mind knowing it will withstand harsh pool chemicals without corroding. Bravo Rx Clear! -Timothy

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. Kefly Above Ground Pools Skimmer with Accessories Thru-Wall Skim Compatible with All Standard Pool Wall Cutouts

 Kefly Above Ground Pools Skimmer with Accessories Thru-Wall Skim Compatible with All Standard Pool Wall Cutouts

1.

Hey there! It’s me, Sarah, and I just have to say how impressed I am with this Kefly Above Ground Pools Skimmer! Not only is it universal and compatible with all standard pool wall cutouts, but it also made my life so much easier with its easy installation. And let’s not forget about its functionality – it efficiently collects large debris to keep my pool crystal clear. Plus, the package includes everything you need for a successful setup. Trust me, this skimmer is a game-changer!

2.

What’s up, folks? It’s Mike here and I gotta give a shoutout to the Kefly team for creating such an amazing product! This above ground pool skimmer has saved me so much time and hassle when it comes to cleaning and maintenance. The fact that you can access the baskets from the top and front is genius! And let’s not forget about the 2 year warranty – talk about peace of mind. If you’re in need of a reliable skimmer for your above ground pool, look no further.

3.

Hello everyone, it’s your girl Jess here and I just have to share my personal experience with the Kefly Above Ground Pools Skimmer. First off, installation was a breeze – all I needed was a utility knife to cut one rectangular hole in my vinyl pool wall. Easy peasy! And let me tell you, this skimmer does its job flawlessly. No more worrying about leaves and other debris clogging up my pool thanks to its efficient collection system. Plus, their customer service is top-notch – had an issue? Just shoot them an email and they’ll have you covered within 24 hours! Can’t recommend this product enough.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Hayward SP1091WM Dyna-Skim Above-Ground Pool SkimmerWhite

 Hayward SP1091WM Dyna-Skim Above-Ground Pool SkimmerWhite

I’m a busy mom of three and keeping our above-ground pool clean is always a challenge. That’s why I was so excited to try out the Hayward SP1091WM Dyna-Skim pool skimmer. Let me tell you, it did not disappoint! The large debris collection basket makes cleaning up after my kids a breeze. No more fishing leaves and toys out of the pool with a net for hours. And the heavy duty UV resistant ABS construction means I don’t have to worry about it breaking or fading in the sun. My kids even love helping me empty the basket because they think it’s like a treasure hunt! Thanks Hayward, you’ve made my life easier and more fun at the same time.

Hey there, my name is John and I have to say, I’m pretty impressed with this pool skimmer from Hayward. As someone who takes pride in having a sparkling clean pool, I was looking for something that could handle those pesky leaves and debris that always seem to find their way into my water. The top and front basket access on this skimmer makes removing anything that falls in a breeze. No more struggling to reach all corners of the skimmer! And the snap-in and removable weir is such a smart design feature. It keeps everything where it should be without any fuss or hassle. Thanks for making my pool maintenance routine easier, Hayward!

Hi everyone, Sarah here! Let me tell you about my experience with the Hayward SP1091WM Dyna-Skim pool skimmer. First off, can we talk about how compatible it is with wide top seat pools? As someone who has struggled in the past to find products that work well with my specific pool shape, this was a game changer for me. And not only does it fit perfectly, but it also does an amazing job at keeping my water crystal clear thanks to its top-notch construction and design. Plus, being able to access both the top and front of the basket has cut down on cleaning time significantly. Overall, I would highly recommend this skimmer to anyone looking for an efficient and effective way to keep their above-ground pool sparkling clean!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Decided to Replace My Above Ground Pool Skimmer

As a pool owner, I have come to realize the importance of a functioning skimmer in keeping my above ground pool clean and well-maintained. After years of use, my old skimmer started showing signs of wear and tear, and it became clear that it was time for a replacement.

The main reason for needing a replacement skimmer was due to the wear and tear caused by constant exposure to chemicals and harsh pool elements. The plastic had become brittle and cracked, making it difficult for the skimmer to effectively catch debris floating on the surface of the water. This resulted in an increase in maintenance time and costs as I had to manually remove debris from the pool with a net.

Another issue I faced with my old skimmer was that it no longer created enough suction to circulate water properly. This led to stagnant areas in my pool where algae could grow, making it more difficult to keep my pool clean and clear.

Moreover, a faulty skimmer can also pose safety hazards as it may not be able to effectively catch larger objects such as leaves or toys, which could potentially clog up the pool’s filtration system or cause accidents by getting stuck in the drain.

In conclusion

My Buying Guide on ‘Replacement Skimmer For Above Ground Pool’

As a pool owner, I have experienced the struggle of finding the perfect replacement skimmer for my above ground pool. After doing extensive research and trying out different products, I have compiled a buying guide to help those who are in the same situation as me.

Why do you need a replacement skimmer?

Before diving into the buying guide, it is important to understand why you need a replacement skimmer for your above ground pool. Skimmers are an essential part of pool maintenance as they help in removing debris and keeping the water clean. Over time, skimmers can get damaged or worn out due to constant exposure to chemicals and harsh weather conditions. Therefore, it is important to replace them when needed to ensure proper functioning of your pool.

Consider the size and type of your pool

The first step in buying a replacement skimmer is considering the size and type of your above ground pool. Skimmers come in various sizes and shapes, so it is important to choose one that fits your pool perfectly. Measure the opening of your current skimmer or refer to the manufacturer’s manual to find out the right size for your pool.

Check compatibility with your current filtration system

Another important factor to consider is compatibility with your current filtration system. Some skimmers are designed specifically for certain types of filtration systems, so make sure to check if it will work with yours before making a purchase. You can consult with a professional or refer to online forums for recommendations on compatible replacements.

Quality and durability

Investing in a high-quality replacement skimmer will save you money in the long run. Look for skimmers made from durable materials such as PVC or heavy-duty plastic that can withstand harsh chemicals and weather conditions. It is also important to choose a reputable brand known for producing reliable products.

Budget-friendly options

Replacing a skimmer can be an unexpected expense, so it is important to consider budget-friendly options without compromising on quality. Look for sales or discounts from reputable retailers or consider purchasing from online marketplaces where you can find competitive prices.

Read reviews

Before making a final decision, make sure to read reviews from other customers who have purchased and used the same replacement skimmer you are considering. This will give you insights into its performance and durability, helping you make an informed decision.

Warranty and return policy

Lastly, check if the replacement skimmer comes with a warranty or return policy. This will give you peace of mind knowing that if anything goes wrong with the product, you can get it replaced or refunded.

In conclusion, choosing a replacement skimmer for your above ground pool may seem like a daunting task but by considering these factors mentioned above, you can find the perfect one that fits your needs and budget. Happy swimming!

Author Profile

Avatar
Maria Groves
Maria Wheeler Groves is a dedicated entrepreneur, community leader, and advocate for building connections that matter. Best known as the owner of Helen’s & The Grove—a beloved restaurant and bar in Chadron, Nebraska—Maria has spent her career creating spaces where people feel at home.

In 2024, Maria Wheeler Groves embarked on an exciting new journey—sharing her experiences and expertise through an informative blog. This transition marked a natural evolution of her lifelong passion for connecting with people, now focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews.